主办者举办这类比赛的理由:我所听到的是“现在的无级棋手越来越怕输”!!! 如果允许“有级棋手”参加,无级棋手将没有机会得奖,他们就不会报名参加,这样棋赛的参赛人数就有欠理想,主办者不能向主办机构与赞助商交差。
我怀疑的是:我们的无级棋手是不是那么没有斗志?那么怕输?还是主办者自己的凭空猜测???
有机会和有级的棋手切磋,提高棋艺,那是非常难得的机会!怎么会因为怕输而不参加呢?如果有棋手有这样的心态,我劝他回家睡觉算了,不要污辱了“象棋”!!!
May be we should consider a long term solution ......
for a competition for all grades, attention will be given to less time will be required, e.g. 2005 and 2006 Singapore Open, but the system not fully tested for at least 3 years and dropped.
in chinese, for a team event, we could consider the sequence of upper horse, middle horse and lower horse, but for an individual event, to have 3 different groups before the competition started should be a fair and better system.
Duration and funding are the two main factors in addition to the more critical factor of manpower needed.
For ideal situation, we should have the method like Divisions A, B, C & D etc and to cater for promotion and demotion each year.
Within Bishan Club, we used round robin system before 2006 for up to 16 players, and managed to introduce the Division system in 2006 and 2007 due to less number of players (24 in 2006 and 20 in 2007) and the player(s) could be promoted to Division A or demoted to Division D within the same year, the concept is same as round robin system but less number of rounds for most of the players by using division system.
With bigger number of players, more years may be needed for promotion and demotion.