讨论新加坡法律我用英文了哦
所在版块:狮城财经 发贴时间:2017-01-20 07:15

用户信息
复制本帖HTML代码
高亮: 今天贴 X 昨天贴 X 前天贴 X 
Disclaimer: I am NOT a criminal lawyer. You are NOT my client. This is NOT a legal advice. I do not assume any responsibility if you choose to rely on the following information. You should engage a criminal lawyer if you are serious about the answer to your query.

I would frame the issue in the following manner: whether or not it is a offence for a person to procure or offer to procure a loan for a consideration which is more than the principal sum from the a non-specific person in public who presumably neither possesses a moneylender licence nor is an exempted moneylender?

The Short answer is: Yes, it is an offence under Moneylenders Acts s 14 which is punishable under s 14(1A) read together with s 109 of the penal code.

Summarised analysis:
1. it is presumed to be illegal for a person who is not your friend or your relative to lend you money with a interest (ss 1, 3 and 5 of the Moneylenders Act).
2. Although you may feel free argue that a person you get "acquainted" via the internet is your friend, a random person is not likely to be capable of rebutting the presumption made by the law based on my understanding of the case law.
3. Hence, the person who agrees to make a loan to you with an interest will have committed a crime (s 14 of the Moneylenders Act). You equally will have have committed the crime of conspiracy by abetment (s 109 of the Penal Code). The factual pattern (i.e. you invite a unknown person to make a loan to you and charge an interest) is supported in the case of Ho Sheng Yu Garreth v Public Prosecutor [2012] 2 SLR 375.

I am not saying that you SURELY WILL be so charged and so convicted. I am saying there is a good chance that you will.

我不想延伸到其他法律问题了。写这篇回答已经用了我一个小时了。你还有其他兴趣的话可以自己花钱请专门做刑法的律师问。
.
欢迎来到华新中文网,踊跃发帖是支持我们的最好方法!

 相关帖子 我要回复↙ ↗回到正文
[提示] 该主题违反版规或内容不当已被屏蔽, 如有疑问请去《意见公告版》投诉. BUTTERFLYGIRL   (123 bytes , 3518reads )
又想起前一阵在隔壁论坛看的帖子 走走   (182 bytes , 58reads )
我觉得护照不用弄假的呀,说搞丢了挂失办一本新的就可以?别人拿着楼主的护照[…] 小妖霖霖   (18 bytes , 48reads )
私人借贷确实违法。 小妖霖霖   (163 bytes , 46reads )
谁说的新加坡收利息的私人借钱违法? 快快跑   (50 bytes , 134reads )
anyway 置顶版规也说了本版禁止私人交易帖 小妖霖霖   (116 bytes , 42reads )
暴雪来了,找他去讨论。删贴请随意 快快跑   (0 bytes , 43reads )
基本上,在没有牌照的前提下, 南洋暴雪   (84 bytes , 51reads )
一个字都没提过删帖,删不删跟我没关系,大家随意。我只对法律有兴趣,这个不能随意 快快跑   (165 bytes , 370reads )
讨论新加坡法律我用英文了哦 南洋暴雪   (1804 bytes , 93reads )
首先逻辑完整,点赞。但重点部分讨论不深 快快跑   (765 bytes , 70reads )
问题是如果两个月就能还上,不然就多等两个月再申请 urwing   (60 bytes , 45reads )
利息5000的话我借你 我来看你了   (0 bytes , 47reads )
你找朋友借吧 如果多几个人凑凑还行 暗霓   (18 bytes , 45reads )
谢谢,i know it's hard, but i have to try... BUTTERFLYGIRL   (0 bytes , 46reads )
楼主没有现实中的亲人朋友吗 小妖霖霖   (18 bytes , 37reads )
前两天一个亲戚找我们帮忙写起诉状 走走   (104 bytes , 51reads )
2级id 遥祝了 目测没有信用 功夫熊猫   (0 bytes , 36reads )
就算十级ID,难道就能借么? 微蓝   (121 bytes , 38reads )
目测本座的信用秒杀层主 功夫熊猫   (0 bytes , 33reads )
跟国内的诈骗电话一样 金沙子   (20 bytes , 48reads )
看了下楼主最近发帖,宝宝还在吃奶瓶,什么样的宝宝入学需要十万新币…… 小妖霖霖   (8 bytes , 63reads )
吃奶瓶? 大草   (34 bytes , 35reads )
好吧,是为了申请宝宝学生证,ICA明说了要存款证明,托儿所院长说了要起码10万的存款 BUTTERFLYGIRL   (0 bytes , 66reads )
搞笑了呢 CrystalAir   (189 bytes , 52reads )
有也不借啊 自信灬微笑   (102 bytes , 53reads )
好奇 人在狮城2016   (26 bytes , 44reads )
发帖数14的账号。。。 疯狂的加菲   (57 bytes , 48reads )
加油 小寒   (38 bytes , 41reads )
2个月2%利息,其实也不少 中级民工   (300 bytes , 55reads )
我有租房契约,有租房押金收据,押金就有近两千了 BUTTERFLYGIRL   (222 bytes , 60reads )
目测不会有人借的 明楼   (11 bytes , 40reads )
这事不能请律师吧 武汉伢   (103 bytes , 45reads )
既然违法 hdeksa   (16 bytes , 35reads )
不违法,谁说违法? 快快跑   (0 bytes , 48reads )
帖子可以不删吗?也许有好心人会看见 BUTTERFLYGIRL   (0 bytes , 62reads )
我有个朋友愿意借给你 gagger   (353 bytes , 52reads )
我也可以借,而且不收利息(怕违法),纯善心无限 华生之友   (39 bytes , 49reads )
Idea not bad ce3873   (35 bytes , 47reads )
这叫做诈骗 南洋暴雪   (14 bytes , 57reads )
这种类型的借款需要有抵押物 滚雪球   (297 bytes , 40reads )
支持删帖 松鼠有榛子   (18 bytes , 42reads )
支持财经版主删帖 武汉伢   (0 bytes , 44reads )
hdeksa   (85 bytes , 39reads )
删帖吧 x4   (28 bytes , 41reads )
伤不起 hdeksa   (14 bytes , 34reads )
找送女雇员Iphone 7的老板借吧, 格布   (76 bytes , 52reads )
为什么利息高反而没人敢借? 我可以先把利息付给你,护照抵押给你,逃不掉啊 BUTTERFLYGIRL   (0 bytes , 55reads )
护照有什么用啊 elainesun   (46 bytes , 38reads )
违法啊当然没人敢借给你 松鼠有榛子   (4 bytes , 38reads )
你还是放弃吧,除非傻子会借给你! 微蓝   (176 bytes , 40reads )
亲戚朋友借的钱都拿不回来 月光下跳舞   (134 bytes , 44reads )
建议清除 春天来了   (48 bytes , 31reads )
借或者不借取决于借款人,骗子行骗也不是因为我的一个帖子,别那么搞笑好不好? BUTTERFLYGIRL   (108 bytes , 56reads )
你是想给宝宝办学生证吧 elainesun   (198 bytes , 49reads )
要是月薪超过5千 喜欢吃火锅   (74 bytes , 42reads )
为什么不跟银行贷款? hdeksa   (10 bytes , 49reads )
申请过,被拒了 BUTTERFLYGIRL   (0 bytes , 46reads )